Youtuber CGP Grey wants to get rid of nickels

Poll of the Day

Poll of the Day » Youtuber CGP Grey wants to get rid of nickels
Here's his video. He goes into other points too

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=58SrtQNt4YE

He made a popular video years ago about getting red of pennies
I really mean that much to you?
Girl, You Know It's True
Just get rid of the last digit all together.

Instead of $1.00, it should read $1.0

Then we phase out the final decimal place later so it is just $1.
The hell was with his microphone for all of this, there's so many cuts.
'Get rid of all coins besides quarters'

I'd pick a (dirty) quarter off of the ground. Dimes as well, but it takes longer due to their size and in public places that makes you stand out.

If pennies ultimately go (in the U.s), I say Lincoln's face has to be transferred to one of the other coins by hilarious rule.
I too had his video recommended to me by Almighty Algorithm. Praise be to our digital master!


There is logic to his argument. Unfortunately, if we still psychologically resist getting rid of pennies, good luck getting rid of something that magnifies the entire problem by x5.

Though he accidentally stumbles on the real solution in his video without realizing it. If we should do away with pennies because each cent actually costs two cents to make, while each nickel costs 9 cents, then obviously we just need to make nickels out of penny material. BOOM - we've just created 3 cents out of nothing. Magic!
"Wall of Text'D!" --- oldskoolplayr76
"POwned again." --- blight family
Lets just get rid of money
VioletZer0 posted...
Just get rid of the last digit all together.

Instead of $1.00, it should read $1.0

Then we phase out the final decimal place later so it is just $1.

That doesn't really work because quarters are still a useful level of granularity at the consumer level. That would limit the subdivisions to halves, fifths, and tenths. Halves are too large, fifths are kind of awkward, and tenths are too small. Halves and fifths would also require new denominations of cash (even if the half-dollar has existed before).

Obviously on the industry side of things there can be as many decimal places as you need, but making decisions for the consumer side of things needs to take into account what's convenient to pay in cash. In that regard, quarters are useful, everything smaller sucks.

ParanoidObsessive posted...
There is logic to his argument. Unfortunately, if we still psychologically resist getting rid of pennies, good luck getting rid of something that magnifies the entire problem by x5.

Indeed. Even getting rid of everything smaller than quarters would have a pretty negligible impact for people's overall finances (testing it out on some of my personal finances, it worked out to losing a couple dollars when I'd spent ~$50k in the year), but people tend to fixate on the idea that they'll be ripped off by rounding and let that blind them to the benefits.
This is my signature. It exists to keep people from skipping the last line of my posts.
MICHALECOLE posted...
Lets just get rid of money

Plenty of people want this. Or at the very least, turn everything into digital credit, so you have to pay by card or your phone and physical cash no longer exists.

For me, I just hope all you bastards get trapped in red tape and social inertia so you can't pull anything like this off until after I die. I kind of hate the entire concept of that future and want to avoid it as long as possible.
"Wall of Text'D!" --- oldskoolplayr76
"POwned again." --- blight family
ParanoidObsessive posted...
Plenty of people want this. Or at the very least, turn everything into digital credit, so you have to pay by card or your phone and physical cash no longer exists.

For me, I just hope all you bastards get trapped in red tape and social inertia so you can't pull anything like this off until after I die. I kind of hate the entire concept of that future and want to avoid it as long as possible.

If I label it as "credit chips" it's sufficiently scifi and rolls back around to being cool.
shadowsword87 posted...
If I label it as "credit chips" it's sufficiently scifi and rolls back around to being cool.

No, you have to make it a disc that you have to scan, and it glows like it's out of Tron. Then you've got me.

https://youtu.be/Pj-MggKGSl4?t=74
"Wall of Text'D!" --- oldskoolplayr76
"POwned again." --- blight family
ParanoidObsessive posted...
No, you have to make it a disc that you have to scan, and it glows like it's out of Tron. Then you've got me.
Just tattoo everyone with bar codes.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=47TZ9MHI1qg
Minutus cantorum, minutus balorum,
Minutus carborata descendum pantorum.
Poll of the Day » Youtuber CGP Grey wants to get rid of nickels