Both people are idiots:
1) You don't go to a movie on the first date. You want interaction, not staring at a screen in silence.
2) If you need to text someone, go outside the theater rather then doing it in your seat.
3) TAKE SEPARATE CARS ON A FIRST DATE!!!! Good god it is like people want to get murdered.
4) If you are 37 years old and care so much about "loosing" $17, then you have failed at life.
I would give the edge to him though, he looks like a forever alone.
I am a senior software engineer. If you see me post here, I am tired of writing TPS reports.